The Institutional Critique of Effective Altruism - Brian Berkey, Utilitas (2017)

web

Cambridge University Press(peer-reviewed)·cambridge.org/core/journals/utilitas/article/abs/institut...

Credibility Rating

5/5

Gold(5)

Gold standard. Rigorous peer review, high editorial standards, and strong institutional reputation.

Rating inherited from publication venue: Cambridge University Press

A peer-reviewed philosophy paper relevant to debates about whether EA's individualistic charitable focus conflicts with systemic/institutional reform; tangentially relevant to AI safety insofar as EA frameworks shape AI safety cause prioritization and funding strategies.

Metadata

Importance: 35/100journal articleanalysis

Summary

Brian Berkey's 2017 paper in Utilitas examines and responds to the 'institutional critique' of effective altruism, which argues that EA's focus on individual charitable giving diverts attention from systemic and structural reform. Berkey evaluates whether this critique undermines EA's core approach and argues that the tension between individual action and institutional change is less damaging to EA than critics suggest.

Key Points

•The institutional critique holds that EA's emphasis on individual donations neglects the importance of systemic/structural change for addressing global problems.
•Berkey argues that EA's framework is not inherently incompatible with supporting institutional and political reform.
•The paper distinguishes between EA as a personal ethics framework and broader questions about optimal collective strategy.
•Published in Utilitas, a leading journal of utilitarian and consequentialist ethics, lending it academic credibility.
•Relevant to debates about whether cause prioritization and individual impact focus crowd out advocacy for systemic change.

Cited by 1 page

Page	Type	Quality
EA and Longtermist Wins and Losses	--	53.0

Cached Content Preview

HTTP 200Fetched Apr 7, 202646 KB

The Institutional Critique of Effective Altruism | Utilitas | Cambridge Core 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

 
 

 

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

 
 

 
 

 
 

 

 

 

 Logo for Cambridge Core from Cambridge University Press. Click to return to homepage. Search Logo for Cambridge Core from Cambridge University Press. Click to return to homepage. Institution Login Search Menu links

 Browse
 Subjects
 Subjects (A-D)
 Anthropology 
 Archaeology 
 Area Studies 
 Art 
 Chemistry 
 Classical Studies 
 Computer Science 
 Drama, Theatre, Performance Studies 
 Subjects (E-K)
 Earth and Environmental Science 
 Economics 
 Education 
 Engineering 
 English Language Teaching – Resources for Teachers 
 Film, Media, Mass Communication 
 General Science 
 Geography 
 History 
 Subjects (L-O)
 Language and Linguistics 
 Law 
 Life Sciences 
 Literature 
 Management 
 Materials Science 
 Mathematics 
 Medicine 
 Music 
 Nutrition 
 Subjects (P-Z)
 Philosophy 
 Physics and Astronomy 
 Politics and International Relations 
 Psychiatry 
 Psychology 
 Religion 
 Social Science Research Methods 
 Sociology 
 Statistics and Probability 
 Open access
 All open access publishing
 Open access 
 Open access journals 
 Research open journals 
 Journals containing open access 
 Open access articles 
 Open access books 
 Open access Elements 
 Journals
 Explore
 All journal subjects 
 Search journals 
 Open access
 Open access journals 
 Research open journals 
 Journals containing open access 
 Open access articles 
 Collections
 Cambridge Forum 
 Cambridge Law Reports Collection 
 Cambridge Prisms 
 Research Directions 
 Books
 Explore
 Books 
 Open access books 
 New books 
 Flip it Open 
 Collections
 Cambridge Companions 
 Cambridge Editions 
 Cambridge Histories 
 Cambridge Library Collection 
 Cambridge Shakespeare 
 Cambridge Handbooks 
 Collections (cont.)
 Dispute Settlement Reports Online 
 Flip it Open 
 Hemingway Letters 
 Shakespeare Survey 
 Stahl Online 
 The Correspondence of Isaac Newton 
 Elements
 Explore
 About Elements 
 Elements series 
 Open access Elements 
 New Elements 
 Subjects (A-E)
 Anthropology 
 Archaeology 
 Classical Studies 
 Computer Science 
 Drama, Theatre, Performance Studies 
 Earth and Environmental Sciences 
 Economics 
 Education 
 Engineering 
 Subjects (F-O)
 Film, Media, Mass Communication 
 History 
 Language and Linguistics 
 Law 
 Life Sciences 
 Literature 
 Management 
 Mathematics 
 Medicine 
 Music 
 Subjects (P-Z)
 Philosophy 
 Physics and Astronomy 
 Politics and International Relations 
 Psychology 
 Religion 
 Sociology 
 Statistics and Probability 
 Textbooks
 Explore
 Cambridge Higher Education 
 Title list 
 New titles 
 Collections
 Book collections
 Cambridge Companions 
 Cambridge Editions 
 Cambridge Histories 
 Cambridge Library Collection 
 Cambridge Shakespeare 
 Cambridge 

... (truncated, 46 KB total)

Resource ID: 5a5d7ced97b6a7a4 | Stable ID: sid_XQuzIlDBLN